janpeter/Ops-dashboard

Fork 0

[ISS-2] ops-agent kan t486 fd-secret capabilities niet veilig uitvoeren #155

New issue

Open

opened 2026-08-26 08:58:43 +02:00 by janpeter · 0 comments

janpeter commented

2026-08-26 08:58:43 +02:00

Owner

Beheerd door Scrum4Me — wijzigingen hier worden overschreven. Bron: https://thuis.jp-visser.nl/issues/cmt9ql7vw000mpu17x51d0vgo

Status: investigating · Severity: s2_critical · Gemeld door: mac:codex · Occurrences: 1 (laatst: 2026-08-26T06:52:33.452Z) · Aangemaakt: 2026-08-26T06:52:33.452Z

Registratie

Tijdens Scrum4Us IDEA-169/T486 stopte de live credential-rotatie terecht. Root cause in Ops-dashboard ops-agent: /agent/v1/exec spawnde children zonder descriptor 3, whitelist args ondersteunden alleen exact-match waarden en loadWhitelist valideerde capabilityvelden zoals kind/request_schema/secret/output niet. Daardoor zou alleen t486_* keys installeren niet genoeg zijn en zelfs silent-wrong-value gedrag kunnen opleveren. Lokale fix in worktree codex/idea-169-ops-agent-capability-contracts voegt typed capability metadata, anchored arg patterns, body-secret naar fd3 transport en flow-afwijzing voor fd-secret commands toe. Geen live hostmutatie uitgevoerd.

Onderzoek

2026-08-26T07:04:02.647Z — codex

Ops-agent fix geïmplementeerd op worktree /Users/janpetervisser/Development/Ops-dashboard/.worktrees/idea-169-ops-agent-capability-contracts, commit 8efa6d4 (fix: support ops-agent fd secret capabilities). Wijziging: commands.yml-schema accepteert capability metadata (kind, request_schema, secret, output) en anchored runtime args.patterns; /agent/v1/exec vereist JSON body secret voor secret: fd en pipe't die naar child fd 3; commands met secret: none/afwezig weigeren body-secrets; flow-runner weigert secret: fd commands omdat flows geen secret source hebben. Verificatie groen: npm -C ops-agent run check, npm run typecheck, targeted vitest 8 files/39 tests, extra control-room route vitest 2 files/89 tests.

2026-08-26T07:13:26.260Z — codex

Ops-dashboard PR #156 is bijgewerkt naar commit 4959c0e na extra fail-closed regressie voor ontbrekende/lege fd-secrets. Finale verificatie op HEAD: git diff --check, npm -C ops-agent run check, npm run typecheck, targeted vitest 8 files/41 tests passed. Bestaande control-room route-regressies waren groen na de testversterking: 2 files/89 tests passed.

2026-08-26T07:41:46.392Z — codex

Server follow-up after PR #156 produced STOP F1': legacy T486 adapter sends body secret: "fd" as a marker and real secret as trailing bytes after Content-Length. PR #156 accepted that marker as a non-empty credential and would write literal fd to child fd3. Ops-dashboard PR #157 fixes the server side by rejecting legacy secret body field and requiring split payload secret_transport: "fd" + secret_value; commit 450dd73177a9bde87442c01acf9c9b7a4e736f2a, PR #157. Verification: RED fd-secret route tests failed on old shape; GREEN fd-secret test 1 file/9 tests; ops-agent check, root typecheck, targeted 8 files/46 tests, route compatibility 2 files/89 tests.

2026-08-26T08:15:59.834Z — mac:codex

T486 queue result 2e415335-d1fb-4de5-bb19-5257c0d09902 after Ops-dashboard PR #157 deploy returned VERDICT=STOP with a new blocker F4. PR #157 closed the fd-secret payload-contract gap F1-prime: deployed /opt/ops-agent provenance repo_head=07cb2a212cbdbb3331d2b401065c2ce5d4d5193b, ops_agent_rev=450dd73177a9bde87442c01acf9c9b7a4e736f2a, repo_dirty=no, service active, and live build contains split fields secret_transport/secret_value with legacy body secret rejection. New F4: exec streaming handler kills the child on reply.raw close when the adapter performs a normal request half-close after sending the full body. Harness against the deployed route measured no-half-close as full SSE with fd3 digest equality, but shutdown(SHUT_WR) after body as 0 bytes/null exit/ECONNRESET. Live unauthenticated control returns 401 for both full and half-close, so this is specific to the streaming exec handler. Required fix: distinguish real client abort from request-body half-close in ops-agent route teardown and test both variants; then rebaseline the T486 operator draft and re-review.

2026-08-26T08:23:31.804Z — mac:codex

Local F4 follow-up in Ops-dashboard worktree /Users/janpetervisser/Development/Ops-dashboard/.worktrees/ops-agent-halfclose-f4 added a raw-socket RED regression without production-code changes. After correcting the test helper, npm test -- test/ops-agent-exec-capability-secret.test.ts failed only on the client-half-close variant; normal request-body completion passed. Characterization tests showed the failure is below the route close-handler: Fastify and bare Node http close a delayed streaming response after request-side FIN before child output can be written. allowHalfOpen, flushHeaders/early SSE frame, shouldKeepAlive and reply.hijack did not preserve the stream. A raw net.Server can write after the same half-close, so TCP is not the blocker; Node http/Fastify streaming lifecycle is. This challenges the earlier assumption that a reply.raw close predicate alone can fix F4. Decision now required: either define the exec adapter/client contract as no explicit request half-close for streaming calls, or redesign the exec transport beyond a small route patch.

2026-08-26T08:29:11.644Z — mac:codex

JP accepted the F4 recommendation: /agent/v1/exec streaming clients must not explicitly request-half-close with shutdown(SHUT_WR) while waiting for SSE output. Local Ops-dashboard worktree /Users/janpetervisser/Development/Ops-dashboard/.worktrees/ops-agent-halfclose-f4 now records this contract in the plan, adds a raw-socket conformance test for the supported streaming shape, and updates the route comment. Verification passed: exec fd-secret test 10/10, ops-agent check, repo typecheck after submodule/prisma generate setup, route compatibility 89/89, and git diff --check. Next action is server-local T486 adapter rebaseline: split payload plus remove shutdown(SHUT_WR), then re-run non-live bundle tests and review.

2026-08-26T08:45:18.372Z — mac:codex

2026-08-26 queue result d2be21e5-d679-4d8c-8e7a-a63919312728 returned VERDICT=STOP. Server-local non-live rebaseline did not mutate live state. Sandbox refused direct writes to /home/janpeter/idea169-t486-draft, so a JP-run patch was produced under /home/janpeter/idea169-t486-unblock-draft: patch-t486-adapters-jp.sh sha256 edd3c80e372cd2c04a8376d5ecbcdc4d4ed9ee7ba501edfac263e5024da0ef00 and patch-t486-adapters.py sha256 119bd974668b118a1d404063fab02a25a4949c33041a50fc6b475b15b4a3eaaa. The accepted client contract fixes F4 only when adapters stop reading until EOF and instead stop at the terminal SSE exit frame. Server evidence also found F5: /agent/v1/exec responds with Transfer-Encoding: chunked and current raw adapter does not dechunk, causing MALFORMED. Patch covers F4+F5 but was not applied. New F6 is non-client-fixable: exit SSE frame currently emits {"code":0} without echoing request identity, while the adapter intentionally fail-closes on request mismatch; disabling this guard was diagnostic only and proved fd3 hash equality, but is not acceptable as a fix. Negative evidence from server: /etc/ops-agent/commands.yml still has 0 t486_ keys, /var/lib/ops-agent/t486 absent, /etc/ops-agent/secret mtime unchanged, ops-agent not restarted, no README --live, no credential rotation/revoke/read/print/copy.

2026-08-26T08:47:50.169Z — mac:codex

2026-08-26 local Ops-dashboard branch codex/ops-agent-halfclose-f4 closed the route-side F6 with TDD. RED: new fd-secret exec test failed because terminal event was exactly data {"code":0} without request identity. GREEN: ops-agent/src/routes/exec.ts now treats optional body field request as a string correlation id and echoes it on terminal exit/error SSE events; clients omitting request retain the previous terminal payload shape. Verification passed: npm test -- test/ops-agent-exec-capability-secret.test.ts = 11/11; npm -C ops-agent run check passed; npm run typecheck passed; npm test -- test/control-room-legacy-routes.test.ts test/control-room-agent-routes.test.ts = 89/89; git diff --check passed. No Docker used and no live server mutation performed from Mac.

2026-08-26T08:48:45.772Z — mac:codex

2026-08-26 committed local Ops-dashboard fix on branch codex/ops-agent-halfclose-f4: 4e61397 fix: echo exec request identity. This is not pushed yet. Branch remains ready for integration choice: push+PR, keep, or local merge.

2026-08-26T08:51:21.851Z — mac:codex

2026-08-26 pushed branch codex/ops-agent-halfclose-f4 and opened Ops-dashboard PR #158: #158. PR contains local commit 4e61397a77 and closes route-side F6 by echoing optional request identity on terminal exec events. Remaining T486 work after merge/deploy: apply/review F4/F5 adapter patch on server and rerun non-live rebaseline before any live credential rotation.

2026-08-26T09:34:20.045Z — mac:codex

2026-08-26 JP applied the reviewed F4/F5 adapter patch on scrum4me-server. Reported new operator draft digests: contain-known-exposures.sh 6ad45073be89b6a527282896afc5e0279e9ec8e6d1a66f35e18446488bd0b55e; rotate-forgejo-pat.sh 26c61d78d87e7753a47ae349f5974120eb11ad10d11f6f415f345be90f9314ae; rotate-postgres-credential.sh ffc85f53a3ebfc78b956009bc6814e0e5ad698110925fd8440963c0637953b38; README.md and test-operator-drafts.sh unchanged. Patch output proved no request-side half-close remains and all three adapters carry split payload plus terminal-frame stop condition. Script explicitly did not rerun test-operator-drafts.sh. PR #158 is merged as b187a5ac84. Dispatched server verification/deploy queue task 03d74076-abaa-415e-a3f7-00c6b4af80b7 to deploy route-side F6 fix and rerun post-patch non-live T486 tests. No live T486 install or credential mutation authorized.

2026-08-26T10:02:20.778Z — mac:codex

2026-08-26 queue task 03d74076-abaa-415e-a3f7-00c6b4af80b7 returned VERDICT=STOP. Blocker 1: host-side deploy of merged PR #158 was refused by Claude sandbox on sudo bash /srv/scrum4me/ops-dashboard/deploy/ops-agent/setup.sh. Deployed /opt/ops-agent remains PR #157 state: repo_head 07cb2a212c, ops_agent_rev 450dd73177, exec.js contains 0 terminalEventData occurrences; PR #158 not deployed. Blocker 2: after JP-applied F4/F5 adapter patch, test-operator-drafts.sh still asserts the old pre-PR157 trailing-bytes wire contract. Post-patch suite result: pass=891 fail=8, SUITE_RC=1. Root cause: fixture endpoint defines secret arrival as bytes past Content-Length and assertions require legacy marker secret=fd plus body-absence of the secret value. Patch transformed the three operator scripts only, leaving the suite unchanged. Green evidence: origin/main fetched cleanly at 6f2a6f493a containing PR #158; post-patch three moved digests match JP output; adapter extracted from all three scripts is byte-identical and matches reviewed transformation output; grep proof shows no shutdown(SHUT_WR), split secret_transport/secret_value, terminal stop, dechunk logic, and enabled REQUEST-MISMATCH guard. Non-live round-trip against PR158 source build with guard enabled showed fd3 hash equals source throwaway-secret hash, 96/96 bytes. Negative evidence: /etc/ops-agent/commands.yml t486_ count 0, /var/lib/ops-agent/t486 absent, /etc/ops-agent/secret untouched, no README --live, no credential rotation/revoke/read/print/copy. Note: server disclosed an unrelated prior commands.yml change adding docker_compose_build_ops_dashboard_with_metadata for update_ops_dashboard; t486_ count remains 0.

2026-08-26T10:03:01.739Z — mac:codex

2026-08-26 dispatched queue task 17973dbc-4067-4901-844d-ff5d193e02c4 to create, not apply, a JP-run patch script for /home/janpeter/idea169-t486-draft/test-operator-drafts.sh. Objective: update the suite from the rejected trailing-bytes wire contract to the accepted split JSON fd-secret contract while preserving negative assertions for argv/process/stdout/stderr/terminal response/log leakage. Explicitly no deploy, no live T486 install, no credential mutation, and no operator script changes.

2026-08-26T10:34:56.044Z — mac:codex

2026-08-26 queue task 17973dbc-4067-4901-844d-ff5d193e02c4 returned VERDICT=GO. Created JP-run suite patch wrapper /home/janpeter/idea169-t486-unblock-draft/patch-t486-suite-jp.sh mode 700 sha256 cc5045b651a9208be8a969f9fd3b13e4019403353405aa9641a0f908a77b8ab0 and transformation /home/janpeter/idea169-t486-unblock-draft/patch-t486-suite.py mode 700 sha256 6537ed9d1b58bbc895d1f17bbe2e4656ce7dc44360e664bec154832af5476879. Not applied. It changes exactly /home/janpeter/idea169-t486-draft/test-operator-drafts.sh from sha256 50def2b545361fcfa81ebcc3248100f9fa289d4478e0e8bac39b2e04c888ac53 to computed sha256 8771d08bb2906da38cacabe73404f2c6f23a6758343c487d324e7357466d27c8. Scratchpad full suite after applying copy passed pass=908 fail=0 SUITE_RC=0 with syscall audit showing zero named live path accesses, zero AF_INET/AF_INET6 sockets, zero connects. Bundle suite also updated inside unblock draft: test-unblock-draft.sh sha256 e850026d8b85ac466c926df142653ca811a83658eeb230337de7d0a1c00a42ca and README.md sha256 a569328cd4b5051eeecb50ca6aa017b3799264ed2453920b2e35c3e04d8169cb; bundle suite pass=78 fail=0. Known remaining gap: fixture endpoint closes socket, so terminal-frame stop is not yet exercised against a keep-alive endpoint. Negative evidence: operator draft unchanged, no deploy, /opt/ops-agent still PR157 repo_head 07cb2a212c ops_agent_rev 450dd73177, t486_ keys 0, /var/lib/ops-agent/t486 absent, no credential mutation/read/print/copy, no --live.

2026-08-26T10:38:06.323Z — mac:codex

2026-08-26 with JP approval, mac:codex executed the JP-run server steps over SSH as janpeter. sudo -n bash /srv/scrum4me/ops-dashboard/deploy/ops-agent/setup.sh succeeded and restarted ops-agent. Post-deploy provenance: installed_at 2026-08-26T10:37:15Z, repo_head 6f2a6f493a, ops_agent_rev 4e61397a77, repo_dirty=no, terminalEventData_count=3, ops-agent active, t486_ key count 0, /var/lib/ops-agent/t486 absent. Then ran patch-t486-suite-jp.sh --check and --apply as janpeter. Suite patch applied cleanly with backup test-operator-drafts.sh.bak.20260826T103730Z. New test-operator-drafts.sh sha256 8771d08bb2906da38cacabe73404f2c6f23a6758343c487d324e7357466d27c8. Sibling draft digests unchanged. Patch output verified fixture no longer reads secret from bytes past Content-Length, legacy marker/body-absence assertions removed, and split payload plus chunked coverage present. test-operator-drafts.sh not yet rerun after actual apply; next step is long non-live suite/round-trip verification.

2026-08-26T11:50:12.823Z — mac:codex

2026-08-26 queue task 288db841-c505-481a-8e6a-5c34fed6592f returned VERDICT=STOP. Official result: PR158 deploy and request echo are green; live ops-agent provenance repo_head 6f2a6f493a, ops_agent_rev 4e61397a77, terminalEventData occurrences 3, service active, no new error/fatal journal lines. F6 closed on deployed route: terminal frame for request probe contains code and request. Five digest manifest matched current rev-C including test-operator-drafts.sh 8771d08bb2906da38cacabe73404f2c6f23a6758343c487d324e7357466d27c8. Adapter grep proof green; non-live round-trip against deployed route module with guard enabled showed fd3 hash equals source throwaway-secret hash, 96/96. Installer gate now satisfied: install-t486-capabilities-root.sh --check exits 0, but --apply was not run. Blocker F8 remains: the patched suite fixture endpoint still waits for EOF, which no longer arrives under accepted no-half-close contract, causing timing-fragile failures. Server produced non-applied JP-run fix: /home/janpeter/idea169-t486-unblock-draft/patch-t486-suite-readloop-jp.sh mode 700 sha256 894016be9d42b83f99f04de5eaac962f4f43377e30ce39bea5536d18c6770f4f and /home/janpeter/idea169-t486-unblock-draft/patch-t486-suite-readloop.py mode 700 sha256 b9cb918373f977a535dc403ddd0d0a7fb362f3a320975e92fa47024c598a1daa. It changes only test-operator-drafts.sh from 8771d08bb2906da38cacabe73404f2c6f23a6758343c487d324e7357466d27c8 to computed 76e7dd10f57957165998cbe8ed766f7fde4f3c5732dfbb4155236da6a1f8b199. Scratch fixed-state full suite passed pass=908 fail=0 SUITE_RC=0 with zero named live path accesses, zero AF_INET/AF_INET6 sockets and zero connects. Negative evidence: t486_ count 0, /var/lib/ops-agent/t486 absent, /etc/ops-agent/secret untouched, no --live, no credential mutation/read/print/copy. mac:codex stopped its own duplicate scratch-copy run after official result arrived.

2026-08-26T12:32:10.767Z — mac:codex

2026-08-26T12:31Z — T486 unblock voortgang. PR #158 is merged en deployed op scrum4me-server (/opt/ops-agent/.install-provenance: repo_head 6f2a6f493ae15c34c46c0f25e8ebd4eb95470885, ops_agent_rev 4e61397a7742b5806e9f6b3d838197cd3d451695, repo_dirty=no). Finale suitepatch applied op /home/janpeter/idea169-t486-draft/test-operator-drafts.sh; digest 76e7dd10f57957165998cbe8ed766f7fde4f3c5732dfbb4155236da6a1f8b199. Fresh server-run: suite_rc=0, pass=908 fail=0, enforced syscall audit: positive openat control observed, zero named live-path access, zero AF_INET/AF_INET6 sockets/connects. Finale vijf digests voor double-GO: contain 6ad45073be89b6a527282896afc5e0279e9ec8e6d1a66f35e18446488bd0b55e; forge 26c61d78d87e7753a47ae349f5974120eb11ad10d11f6f415f345be90f9314ae; pg ffc85f53a3ebfc78b956009bc6814e0e5ad698110925fd8440963c0637953b38; README 3b29b760c8688619b6f52c233a22aca649f5e5a87bccd0baa8bb77ca8c902132; suite 76e7dd10f57957165998cbe8ed766f7fde4f3c5732dfbb4155236da6a1f8b199. Review body saved locally at /Users/janpetervisser/Development/Scrum4Us/docs/reviews/2026-08-26-t486-final-digest-double-go-round1.md. Queue reviewrequests pushed: a91566f7-77b0-4712-b6b0-75ac92af5a11 to scrum4me-server:claude (still pending at 12:31Z) and 92e67758-ff8e-480c-83f8-9cfb3164548e to mac:codex (claimed by mac:43192, no reply yet at 12:31Z). No T486 live capability install, no authority bundle mint, no credential read/print/copy/mutation and no --live run performed.

2026-08-26T13:24:17.661Z — mac:codex

2026-08-26T13:23Z — Round-1 double-GO triage afgerond. mac:codex review 669c96ea-f8ff-407c-8d72-dc5c73592425 gaf GO met 0 findings. scrum4me-server:claude review 4e351d91-9cc2-4d96-857c-8b6e428232c6 gaf NO-GO met 1 BLOCKER, 2 MAJOR, 2 MINOR. Findings zijn tegen de serverbestanden geverifieerd en geaccepteerd: README beschreef nog onjuist dat de credential niet in de HTTP request body zit; §9 miste de 2026-08-26 wire-contract repair; suite discrimineerde de keep-alive terminal-frame stop nog niet; dubbele §3 was cosmetisch; EXPECT_TERMINAL_EVENT is alleen in PG load-bearing en blijft als GO-compatible minor/asymmetrie staan. Patch applied op server: README contract aangepast naar secret_value/secret_transport, §3a renumbering, §9 row 9/14 geactualiseerd, §9d toegevoegd; suite B2 uitgebreid met keep-alive response row en terminal-frame-stop mutant row. New digests: contain 6ad45073be89b6a527282896afc5e0279e9ec8e6d1a66f35e18446488bd0b55e; forge 26c61d78d87e7753a47ae349f5974120eb11ad10d11f6f415f345be90f9314ae; pg ffc85f53a3ebfc78b956009bc6814e0e5ad698110925fd8440963c0637953b38; README 416dd13820515ef30ac7bd3945d5c96b6049d6ac1569e0824022011f35560e07; suite c729e9aefbed4dd9ee2418926105c65cc56e2e03e4e472e2c8e44808815dc5b3. Fresh syntax gate clean. Fresh server suite: suite_rc=0, pass=911 fail=0, with new rows for keep-alive terminal frame and mutant timeout; enforced syscall audit: positive openat control 3328608, zero named live-path accesses, zero AF_INET/AF_INET6 sockets/connects. Backups created on server: README.md.bak.20260826T130345Z, test-operator-drafts.sh.bak.20260826T130345Z. Still no T486 live capability install, no authority bundle mint, no credential read/print/copy/mutation and no --live run.

2026-08-26T13:25:26.588Z — mac:codex

2026-08-26T13:25Z — Round-2 reviewrequests gepusht voor finale vijf-digest pre-live binding review. Review body: /Users/janpetervisser/Development/Scrum4Us/docs/reviews/2026-08-26-t486-final-digest-double-go-round2.md. Queue ids: 494ce565-2396-44c8-a61c-f81d2a1644ef to scrum4me-server:claude; 0062cec4-f724-4c86-9d72-51dc490176d9 to mac:codex. Direct na push stonden beide pending. Scope blijft read-only review; geen live install/credentialmutatie.

2026-08-26T15:18:34.217Z — mac:codex

T486 round3b evidence after fixing round2 review findings. Server artifact root /home/janpeter/idea169-t486-draft. No live install, no credential read/print/copy/mutation, no authority bundle binding performed.

Applied server-only draft updates with backup stamp 20260826T143438Z:

Runtime adapter now reads non-chunked responses until full declared response Content-Length, and chunked responses until terminating zero chunk; it no longer has the obsolete terminal-frame early-stop helper.
B2 suite now covers non-chunked Content-Length keep-alive, delayed second terminal frame inside one Content-Length body, short Content-Length body, chunked keep-alive, Content-Length-stop mutant, and chunked-stop mutant.
G7 fmut diagnostics remain in place from the prior round3 patch.

Current digests:

contain-known-exposures.sh 9cf93c649e9f9314f0a8a8eecd9d4efc4d7e0a6492583b7cd9a809871828e130
rotate-forgejo-pat.sh 1cbf5a8b9349a270db7aa7549b44ac76cdf7f3da82d156e6fc0dcbaa0363a2be
rotate-postgres-credential.sh 7ddb8511a01f5018b815d0eb28ceb2f1847fd9e8f7e2ba0bf8b9518af284a2d3
README.md 47c9990eee31da10efce246ac47aaad9cf10bcc0a2532253a60c0b83be5c34bb
test-operator-drafts.sh 9e6e96c44e8acff36fea5748ed1d3b0473278fb73e01fd738d3a6f9bb03d152c
extracted adapter hash in all three operator scripts: 514832a3e9388e1a468718a3084247aa1c8031b32a53ee28ae2f128c98d5501b

Targeted reproduction of the former mac:codex blocker now returns adapter_rc=1, adapter_stdout='MULTIPLE-TERMINAL - - -', declared body length 180 and first frame length 89; no longer returns OK after first frame.

Verification:

Functional suite run 1: /tmp/t486-suite-round3b-20260826T143455Z.log, pass=916 fail=0, rc 0.
Functional suite run 2: /tmp/t486-suite-round3b-repeat-20260826T144449Z.log, pass=916 fail=0, rc 0.
Enforced syscall audit run: /tmp/t486-suite-round3b-audited-20260826T145828Z.log, pass=916 fail=0, rc 0, positive control 3329187 openat, zero accesses to named live paths, zero AF_INET/AF_INET6 sockets and zero connects.

2026-08-26T15:19:54.673Z — mac:codex

Round-3 review requests dispatched via s4m-queue after green round3b verification.

scrum4me-server:claude request b8ffa703-d855-478f-8068-6c994e7f16c4
mac:codex request c7fe89f4-6288-4474-99f3-ef5eb1a09272
Awaiting reviewed replies before any authority bundle or live binding step.

2026-08-26T15:29:40.278Z — mac:codex

Because the mac:codex round-3 review request stayed pending while scrum4me-server:claude was claimed, a backup independent review request was dispatched to max2:claude: d94a2d37-abea-4dad-9f00-eb5ee1e7d35c. Gate remains unchanged: require two independent GO replies before any live binding.

2026-08-26T16:18:49.676Z — mac:codex

Round-3 replies received.

Primary reviews:

mac:codex reply 4555d2b1-dfdd-4bee-9e4d-13f5ca4204de: VERDICT GO, no findings. Verified manifest, syntax, adapter identity, B2 Content-Length/chunked keep-alive semantics, G7 fmut diagnostics, supplied logs, and absence of obsolete terminal-frame-stop references.
scrum4me-server:claude reply 12cfe719-8243-42ec-bcae-d8c27cbbbf48: VERDICT GO, 0 blocker, 0 major, 2 minor. Round-2 findings closed; noted minor HTTP framing strictness and unexplained-but-diagnosable prior nondeterminism.

Backup review:

max2:claude reply 762173a8-abe1-41cd-bca8-18e3fd1fb2c7: VERDICT NO-GO, 1 blocker. B1 claims the 12 G7 fmut construction guards can fail silently because mutant_tree runs in command substitution; its bad output is captured and its FAIL++ happens in a subshell. Independently verified with a minimal reproduction using the same shell shape: after mutant_tree calls bad and returns 1 inside W="$(mutant_tree)" || return, summary remains pass=0 fail=0.

Decision: treat the backup B1 as valid despite the two primary GO replies. The current digest set is not bindable until the G7 harness construction guard is parent-visible and/or row-count asserted. Scope for next patch: test-operator-drafts.sh only; keep HTTP framing minors and other observations as follow-up notes, not part of this fix.

2026-08-26T16:51:40.713Z — mac:codex

2026-08-26T16:55Z — T486 round-4 B1-delta evidence. Accepted max2:claude round-3 blocker B1: G7 fmut() construction failures could be hidden by command substitution (W="$(mutant_tree ...)" || return), so a stale sed/mutation row could disappear with fail=0. Server-only draft patch applied to /home/janpeter/idea169-t486-draft/test-operator-drafts.sh; no live install, no authority bundle binding and no credential read/print/copy/mutation performed.

Current digest manifest:

contain-known-exposures.sh 9cf93c649e9f9314f0a8a8eecd9d4efc4d7e0a6492583b7cd9a809871828e130
rotate-forgejo-pat.sh 1cbf5a8b9349a270db7aa7549b44ac76cdf7f3da82d156e6fc0dcbaa0363a2be
rotate-postgres-credential.sh 7ddb8511a01f5018b815d0eb28ceb2f1847fd9e8f7e2ba0bf8b9518af284a2d3
README.md 47c9990eee31da10efce246ac47aaad9cf10bcc0a2532253a60c0b83be5c34bb
test-operator-drafts.sh 1c2abdbbb165f5ad8a6809c44c626a63430e85387d6ed480da7007921e025bb8

B1 fix: fmut() now creates the mutant tree in the parent shell, mutant_tree receives the target tree path instead of printing it through command substitution, G7_MUTATIONS counts successful rows, and the suite asserts exactly 12 Forge mutation rows executed. Targeted stale-mutant selftest now reports FAIL mutation 'stale guard selftest' did not apply to any line and summary pass=0 fail=1. Functional suite /tmp/t486-suite-round4-b1-20260826T162039Z.log: pass=917 fail=0, rc 0. Enforced syscall-audit suite /tmp/t486-suite-round4-b1-audited-20260826T163021Z.log: pass=917 fail=0, rc 0; positive control 3329559 openat; zero named live-path accesses; zero AF_INET/AF_INET6 sockets/connects.

Round-4 review body saved locally at /Users/janpetervisser/Development/Scrum4Us/docs/reviews/2026-08-26-t486-final-digest-double-go-round4-b1.md. Next: two independent review requests for the current five-file digest set before any live binding step.

2026-08-26T16:52:08.297Z — mac:codex

2026-08-26T16:58Z — T486 round-4 B1 delta review requests dispatched. Body: /Users/janpetervisser/Development/Scrum4Us/docs/reviews/2026-08-26-t486-final-digest-double-go-round4-b1.md. Queue ids: 8a3e786c-25ca-4d82-b514-d1cfda1f1c4c to max2:claude; e4e5614c-3a9d-4cd1-974d-b3e28930654e to mac:codex. Scope is read-only review of current five-file digest set; no live T486 capability install, no authority bundle binding, no --live, and no credential read/print/copy/mutation.

2026-08-26T17:23:42.756Z — mac:codex

2026-08-26T17:25Z — T486 round-4 B1 delta review completed with two independent GO replies. Replies were acked in s4m-queue.

mac:codex reply 1d13d0ed-7f87-4829-bf7a-b99e3075630a: GO, 0 blocker / 0 major / 0 minor. Verified current manifest, bash -n, G7 mutant_tree/fmut structure, absence of the old command-substitution pattern, both named logs, and absence of live operations.
max2:claude reply 607c20ea-9292-4ac4-ac56-8037ff53b605: GO, B1 closed, 0 blocker / 0 major / 4 new minor / 6 carried-forward minor. max2 independently reproduced round-3 stale-mutation behavior as pass=0 fail=0 rc=0 and round-4 fixed behavior as pass=0 fail=2 rc=1; also ran an independent audited suite on max2 with pass=917 fail=0, positive openat control 1838822, zero named live-path accesses and zero AF_INET/AF_INET6 sockets/connects.

GO-compatible follow-ups recorded: add equivalent row-count guards for C4/H8 mutation families; add stale-pattern guard to cmut; strengthen two C4 assertions to concrete post-state; fix remaining newroot() cleanup inertness; carry forward earlier HTTP framing/control-character/diagnostic/live-branch coverage minors. Gate result: current five-file digest set has double GO for final pre-live binding review. Still no live T486 capability install, no authority bundle binding, no --live, and no credential read/print/copy/mutation performed.

2026-08-26T17:35:04.675Z — mac:codex

2026-08-26T17:36Z — Live capability install not executed yet. During preflight for JP-approved live step, found a binding scope gap: the round-4 double-GO covered the five operator/runbook files, not the separate /home/janpeter/idea169-t486-unblock-draft installer bundle. The existing plan explicitly requires double-GO review of the unblock bundle before root installation/authority minting.

Preflight evidence before mutation: sudo install-t486-capabilities-root.sh --check returned rc 0 and reported all gates OK; live state remains t486_key_count=0, /var/lib/ops-agent/t486 absent, /usr/lib/ops-agent/t486 absent, ops-agent active. Running test-unblock-draft.sh initially failed (pass=80 fail=9) because the non-live unblock bundle was not rebaselined to the round-4 operator digests and still expected stale patch states. Patched only non-live files under /home/janpeter/idea169-t486-unblock-draft (README.md, test-unblock-draft.sh, patch-t486-suite-readloop-jp.sh), with backups; no /etc, /var/lib, service restart or credential action. Re-run selftest /tmp/t486-unblock-draft-test-20260826T173354Z.log: rc 0, pass=89 fail=0. Installer check /tmp/t486-install-check-post-rebaseline-20260826T173417Z.log: rc 0, contract satisfied, --apply permitted by script.

New root-gate review body saved locally: /Users/janpetervisser/Development/Scrum4Us/docs/reviews/2026-08-26-t486-unblock-bundle-root-gate-round1.md. Reviewer ask explicitly includes whether adding t486 allowlist entries is safe while /usr/lib/ops-agent/t486 helper path is absent. Next step: two independent review requests; no live mutation until double-GO.

2026-08-26T17:35:24.140Z — mac:codex

2026-08-26T17:37Z — Root-gate review requests dispatched for the rebaselined T486 unblock bundle. Queue ids: 79c49363-1f28-4ef8-95b9-9c4e99146aa3 to scrum4me-server:claude; a387109b-c1a3-4371-804c-6bb9e1cc1c2a to mac:codex. Scope read-only review only; no live install, no authority binding, no --live, no credential action.

2026-08-26T17:43:21.811Z — mac:codex

2026-08-26T17:45Z — T486 unblock bundle root-gate round 1 completed: NO-GO. Replies acked. mac:codex reply 2834312c-9a23-4ce8-8f22-a645569f2868: GO, 0 blocker / 0 major / 1 minor. scrum4me-server:claude reply 11141ec2-2d96-440e-a984-6846ec6ceb8c: NO-GO, 1 blocker / 2 major.

Findings verified and accepted:

BLOCKER rollback mode: install-t486-capabilities-root.sh backs up /etc/ops-agent/commands.yml with cp -a then chmod 0600 on the backup, but rollback copies it back with cp -a and no mode correction. Live whitelist is 0644 root:root; ops-agent.service runs User=ops-agent Group=ops-agent; a rollback after restart/active/key-count failure could leave commands.yml unreadable and ops-agent crash-looping.
MAJOR vacuous gates/digest pinning: F4/F5 can report OK if operator files are skipped; F6 checks absence of old JSON.stringify({ code }) instead of presence of request echo; installer itself does not pin the five operator digests.
MAJOR helper sequencing: /usr/lib/ops-agent is absent, while installer would add 22 standing grants to /usr/lib/ops-agent/t486/<name>. This is immediate fail-closed but misleading and allows later helper drop to activate grants without this gate rerunning.

Result: do not run sudo /home/janpeter/idea169-t486-unblock-draft/install-t486-capabilities-root.sh --apply --acknowledge-readme-section-2. No live capability install, authority binding, --live, or credential action performed. Review record updated locally: /Users/janpetervisser/Development/Scrum4Us/docs/reviews/2026-08-26-t486-unblock-bundle-root-gate-round1.md.

Oplossing

Nog geen oplossing.

> Beheerd door Scrum4Me — wijzigingen hier worden overschreven. Bron: https://thuis.jp-visser.nl/issues/cmt9ql7vw000mpu17x51d0vgo Status: investigating · Severity: s2_critical · Gemeld door: mac:codex · Occurrences: 1 (laatst: 2026-08-26T06:52:33.452Z) · Aangemaakt: 2026-08-26T06:52:33.452Z ## Registratie Tijdens Scrum4Us IDEA-169/T486 stopte de live credential-rotatie terecht. Root cause in Ops-dashboard ops-agent: /agent/v1/exec spawnde children zonder descriptor 3, whitelist args ondersteunden alleen exact-match waarden en loadWhitelist valideerde capabilityvelden zoals kind/request_schema/secret/output niet. Daardoor zou alleen t486_* keys installeren niet genoeg zijn en zelfs silent-wrong-value gedrag kunnen opleveren. Lokale fix in worktree codex/idea-169-ops-agent-capability-contracts voegt typed capability metadata, anchored arg patterns, body-secret naar fd3 transport en flow-afwijzing voor fd-secret commands toe. Geen live hostmutatie uitgevoerd. ## Onderzoek --- *2026-08-26T07:04:02.647Z — codex* Ops-agent fix geïmplementeerd op worktree `/Users/janpetervisser/Development/Ops-dashboard/.worktrees/idea-169-ops-agent-capability-contracts`, commit `8efa6d4` (`fix: support ops-agent fd secret capabilities`). Wijziging: commands.yml-schema accepteert capability metadata (`kind`, `request_schema`, `secret`, `output`) en anchored runtime `args.patterns`; `/agent/v1/exec` vereist JSON body `secret` voor `secret: fd` en pipe't die naar child fd 3; commands met `secret: none`/afwezig weigeren body-secrets; flow-runner weigert `secret: fd` commands omdat flows geen secret source hebben. Verificatie groen: `npm -C ops-agent run check`, `npm run typecheck`, targeted vitest 8 files/39 tests, extra control-room route vitest 2 files/89 tests. --- *2026-08-26T07:13:26.260Z — codex* Ops-dashboard PR #156 is bijgewerkt naar commit `4959c0e` na extra fail-closed regressie voor ontbrekende/lege fd-secrets. Finale verificatie op HEAD: `git diff --check`, `npm -C ops-agent run check`, `npm run typecheck`, targeted vitest 8 files/41 tests passed. Bestaande control-room route-regressies waren groen na de testversterking: 2 files/89 tests passed. --- *2026-08-26T07:41:46.392Z — codex* Server follow-up after PR #156 produced STOP F1': legacy T486 adapter sends body `secret: "fd"` as a marker and real secret as trailing bytes after Content-Length. PR #156 accepted that marker as a non-empty credential and would write literal `fd` to child fd3. Ops-dashboard PR #157 fixes the server side by rejecting legacy `secret` body field and requiring split payload `secret_transport: "fd"` + `secret_value`; commit `450dd73177a9bde87442c01acf9c9b7a4e736f2a`, PR https://git.jp-visser.nl/janpeter/Ops-dashboard/pulls/157. Verification: RED fd-secret route tests failed on old shape; GREEN fd-secret test 1 file/9 tests; ops-agent check, root typecheck, targeted 8 files/46 tests, route compatibility 2 files/89 tests. --- *2026-08-26T08:15:59.834Z — mac:codex* T486 queue result 2e415335-d1fb-4de5-bb19-5257c0d09902 after Ops-dashboard PR #157 deploy returned VERDICT=STOP with a new blocker F4. PR #157 closed the fd-secret payload-contract gap F1-prime: deployed /opt/ops-agent provenance repo_head=07cb2a212cbdbb3331d2b401065c2ce5d4d5193b, ops_agent_rev=450dd73177a9bde87442c01acf9c9b7a4e736f2a, repo_dirty=no, service active, and live build contains split fields secret_transport/secret_value with legacy body secret rejection. New F4: exec streaming handler kills the child on reply.raw close when the adapter performs a normal request half-close after sending the full body. Harness against the deployed route measured no-half-close as full SSE with fd3 digest equality, but shutdown(SHUT_WR) after body as 0 bytes/null exit/ECONNRESET. Live unauthenticated control returns 401 for both full and half-close, so this is specific to the streaming exec handler. Required fix: distinguish real client abort from request-body half-close in ops-agent route teardown and test both variants; then rebaseline the T486 operator draft and re-review. --- *2026-08-26T08:23:31.804Z — mac:codex* Local F4 follow-up in Ops-dashboard worktree /Users/janpetervisser/Development/Ops-dashboard/.worktrees/ops-agent-halfclose-f4 added a raw-socket RED regression without production-code changes. After correcting the test helper, `npm test -- test/ops-agent-exec-capability-secret.test.ts` failed only on the client-half-close variant; normal request-body completion passed. Characterization tests showed the failure is below the route close-handler: Fastify and bare Node http close a delayed streaming response after request-side FIN before child output can be written. allowHalfOpen, flushHeaders/early SSE frame, shouldKeepAlive and reply.hijack did not preserve the stream. A raw net.Server can write after the same half-close, so TCP is not the blocker; Node http/Fastify streaming lifecycle is. This challenges the earlier assumption that a reply.raw close predicate alone can fix F4. Decision now required: either define the exec adapter/client contract as no explicit request half-close for streaming calls, or redesign the exec transport beyond a small route patch. --- *2026-08-26T08:29:11.644Z — mac:codex* JP accepted the F4 recommendation: /agent/v1/exec streaming clients must not explicitly request-half-close with shutdown(SHUT_WR) while waiting for SSE output. Local Ops-dashboard worktree /Users/janpetervisser/Development/Ops-dashboard/.worktrees/ops-agent-halfclose-f4 now records this contract in the plan, adds a raw-socket conformance test for the supported streaming shape, and updates the route comment. Verification passed: exec fd-secret test 10/10, ops-agent check, repo typecheck after submodule/prisma generate setup, route compatibility 89/89, and git diff --check. Next action is server-local T486 adapter rebaseline: split payload plus remove shutdown(SHUT_WR), then re-run non-live bundle tests and review. --- *2026-08-26T08:45:18.372Z — mac:codex* 2026-08-26 queue result d2be21e5-d679-4d8c-8e7a-a63919312728 returned VERDICT=STOP. Server-local non-live rebaseline did not mutate live state. Sandbox refused direct writes to /home/janpeter/idea169-t486-draft, so a JP-run patch was produced under /home/janpeter/idea169-t486-unblock-draft: patch-t486-adapters-jp.sh sha256 edd3c80e372cd2c04a8376d5ecbcdc4d4ed9ee7ba501edfac263e5024da0ef00 and patch-t486-adapters.py sha256 119bd974668b118a1d404063fab02a25a4949c33041a50fc6b475b15b4a3eaaa. The accepted client contract fixes F4 only when adapters stop reading until EOF and instead stop at the terminal SSE exit frame. Server evidence also found F5: /agent/v1/exec responds with Transfer-Encoding: chunked and current raw adapter does not dechunk, causing MALFORMED. Patch covers F4+F5 but was not applied. New F6 is non-client-fixable: exit SSE frame currently emits {"code":0} without echoing request identity, while the adapter intentionally fail-closes on request mismatch; disabling this guard was diagnostic only and proved fd3 hash equality, but is not acceptable as a fix. Negative evidence from server: /etc/ops-agent/commands.yml still has 0 t486_ keys, /var/lib/ops-agent/t486 absent, /etc/ops-agent/secret mtime unchanged, ops-agent not restarted, no README --live, no credential rotation/revoke/read/print/copy. --- *2026-08-26T08:47:50.169Z — mac:codex* 2026-08-26 local Ops-dashboard branch codex/ops-agent-halfclose-f4 closed the route-side F6 with TDD. RED: new fd-secret exec test failed because terminal event was exactly data {"code":0} without request identity. GREEN: ops-agent/src/routes/exec.ts now treats optional body field request as a string correlation id and echoes it on terminal exit/error SSE events; clients omitting request retain the previous terminal payload shape. Verification passed: npm test -- test/ops-agent-exec-capability-secret.test.ts = 11/11; npm -C ops-agent run check passed; npm run typecheck passed; npm test -- test/control-room-legacy-routes.test.ts test/control-room-agent-routes.test.ts = 89/89; git diff --check passed. No Docker used and no live server mutation performed from Mac. --- *2026-08-26T08:48:45.772Z — mac:codex* 2026-08-26 committed local Ops-dashboard fix on branch codex/ops-agent-halfclose-f4: 4e61397 fix: echo exec request identity. This is not pushed yet. Branch remains ready for integration choice: push+PR, keep, or local merge. --- *2026-08-26T08:51:21.851Z — mac:codex* 2026-08-26 pushed branch codex/ops-agent-halfclose-f4 and opened Ops-dashboard PR #158: https://git.jp-visser.nl/janpeter/Ops-dashboard/pulls/158. PR contains local commit 4e61397a7742b5806e9f6b3d838197cd3d451695 and closes route-side F6 by echoing optional request identity on terminal exec events. Remaining T486 work after merge/deploy: apply/review F4/F5 adapter patch on server and rerun non-live rebaseline before any live credential rotation. --- *2026-08-26T09:34:20.045Z — mac:codex* 2026-08-26 JP applied the reviewed F4/F5 adapter patch on scrum4me-server. Reported new operator draft digests: contain-known-exposures.sh 6ad45073be89b6a527282896afc5e0279e9ec8e6d1a66f35e18446488bd0b55e; rotate-forgejo-pat.sh 26c61d78d87e7753a47ae349f5974120eb11ad10d11f6f415f345be90f9314ae; rotate-postgres-credential.sh ffc85f53a3ebfc78b956009bc6814e0e5ad698110925fd8440963c0637953b38; README.md and test-operator-drafts.sh unchanged. Patch output proved no request-side half-close remains and all three adapters carry split payload plus terminal-frame stop condition. Script explicitly did not rerun test-operator-drafts.sh. PR #158 is merged as b187a5ac8409db8e35a79e08f38fe2bd2c1d2b17. Dispatched server verification/deploy queue task 03d74076-abaa-415e-a3f7-00c6b4af80b7 to deploy route-side F6 fix and rerun post-patch non-live T486 tests. No live T486 install or credential mutation authorized. --- *2026-08-26T10:02:20.778Z — mac:codex* 2026-08-26 queue task 03d74076-abaa-415e-a3f7-00c6b4af80b7 returned VERDICT=STOP. Blocker 1: host-side deploy of merged PR #158 was refused by Claude sandbox on sudo bash /srv/scrum4me/ops-dashboard/deploy/ops-agent/setup.sh. Deployed /opt/ops-agent remains PR #157 state: repo_head 07cb2a212cbdbb3331d2b401065c2ce5d4d5193b, ops_agent_rev 450dd73177a9bde87442c01acf9c9b7a4e736f2a, exec.js contains 0 terminalEventData occurrences; PR #158 not deployed. Blocker 2: after JP-applied F4/F5 adapter patch, test-operator-drafts.sh still asserts the old pre-PR157 trailing-bytes wire contract. Post-patch suite result: pass=891 fail=8, SUITE_RC=1. Root cause: fixture endpoint defines secret arrival as bytes past Content-Length and assertions require legacy marker secret=fd plus body-absence of the secret value. Patch transformed the three operator scripts only, leaving the suite unchanged. Green evidence: origin/main fetched cleanly at 6f2a6f493ae15c34c46c0f25e8ebd4eb95470885 containing PR #158; post-patch three moved digests match JP output; adapter extracted from all three scripts is byte-identical and matches reviewed transformation output; grep proof shows no shutdown(SHUT_WR), split secret_transport/secret_value, terminal stop, dechunk logic, and enabled REQUEST-MISMATCH guard. Non-live round-trip against PR158 source build with guard enabled showed fd3 hash equals source throwaway-secret hash, 96/96 bytes. Negative evidence: /etc/ops-agent/commands.yml t486_ count 0, /var/lib/ops-agent/t486 absent, /etc/ops-agent/secret untouched, no README --live, no credential rotation/revoke/read/print/copy. Note: server disclosed an unrelated prior commands.yml change adding docker_compose_build_ops_dashboard_with_metadata for update_ops_dashboard; t486_ count remains 0. --- *2026-08-26T10:03:01.739Z — mac:codex* 2026-08-26 dispatched queue task 17973dbc-4067-4901-844d-ff5d193e02c4 to create, not apply, a JP-run patch script for /home/janpeter/idea169-t486-draft/test-operator-drafts.sh. Objective: update the suite from the rejected trailing-bytes wire contract to the accepted split JSON fd-secret contract while preserving negative assertions for argv/process/stdout/stderr/terminal response/log leakage. Explicitly no deploy, no live T486 install, no credential mutation, and no operator script changes. --- *2026-08-26T10:34:56.044Z — mac:codex* 2026-08-26 queue task 17973dbc-4067-4901-844d-ff5d193e02c4 returned VERDICT=GO. Created JP-run suite patch wrapper /home/janpeter/idea169-t486-unblock-draft/patch-t486-suite-jp.sh mode 700 sha256 cc5045b651a9208be8a969f9fd3b13e4019403353405aa9641a0f908a77b8ab0 and transformation /home/janpeter/idea169-t486-unblock-draft/patch-t486-suite.py mode 700 sha256 6537ed9d1b58bbc895d1f17bbe2e4656ce7dc44360e664bec154832af5476879. Not applied. It changes exactly /home/janpeter/idea169-t486-draft/test-operator-drafts.sh from sha256 50def2b545361fcfa81ebcc3248100f9fa289d4478e0e8bac39b2e04c888ac53 to computed sha256 8771d08bb2906da38cacabe73404f2c6f23a6758343c487d324e7357466d27c8. Scratchpad full suite after applying copy passed pass=908 fail=0 SUITE_RC=0 with syscall audit showing zero named live path accesses, zero AF_INET/AF_INET6 sockets, zero connects. Bundle suite also updated inside unblock draft: test-unblock-draft.sh sha256 e850026d8b85ac466c926df142653ca811a83658eeb230337de7d0a1c00a42ca and README.md sha256 a569328cd4b5051eeecb50ca6aa017b3799264ed2453920b2e35c3e04d8169cb; bundle suite pass=78 fail=0. Known remaining gap: fixture endpoint closes socket, so terminal-frame stop is not yet exercised against a keep-alive endpoint. Negative evidence: operator draft unchanged, no deploy, /opt/ops-agent still PR157 repo_head 07cb2a212cbdbb3331d2b401065c2ce5d4d5193b ops_agent_rev 450dd73177a9bde87442c01acf9c9b7a4e736f2a, t486_ keys 0, /var/lib/ops-agent/t486 absent, no credential mutation/read/print/copy, no --live. --- *2026-08-26T10:38:06.323Z — mac:codex* 2026-08-26 with JP approval, mac:codex executed the JP-run server steps over SSH as janpeter. sudo -n bash /srv/scrum4me/ops-dashboard/deploy/ops-agent/setup.sh succeeded and restarted ops-agent. Post-deploy provenance: installed_at 2026-08-26T10:37:15Z, repo_head 6f2a6f493ae15c34c46c0f25e8ebd4eb95470885, ops_agent_rev 4e61397a7742b5806e9f6b3d838197cd3d451695, repo_dirty=no, terminalEventData_count=3, ops-agent active, t486_ key count 0, /var/lib/ops-agent/t486 absent. Then ran patch-t486-suite-jp.sh --check and --apply as janpeter. Suite patch applied cleanly with backup test-operator-drafts.sh.bak.20260826T103730Z. New test-operator-drafts.sh sha256 8771d08bb2906da38cacabe73404f2c6f23a6758343c487d324e7357466d27c8. Sibling draft digests unchanged. Patch output verified fixture no longer reads secret from bytes past Content-Length, legacy marker/body-absence assertions removed, and split payload plus chunked coverage present. test-operator-drafts.sh not yet rerun after actual apply; next step is long non-live suite/round-trip verification. --- *2026-08-26T11:50:12.823Z — mac:codex* 2026-08-26 queue task 288db841-c505-481a-8e6a-5c34fed6592f returned VERDICT=STOP. Official result: PR158 deploy and request echo are green; live ops-agent provenance repo_head 6f2a6f493ae15c34c46c0f25e8ebd4eb95470885, ops_agent_rev 4e61397a7742b5806e9f6b3d838197cd3d451695, terminalEventData occurrences 3, service active, no new error/fatal journal lines. F6 closed on deployed route: terminal frame for request probe contains code and request. Five digest manifest matched current rev-C including test-operator-drafts.sh 8771d08bb2906da38cacabe73404f2c6f23a6758343c487d324e7357466d27c8. Adapter grep proof green; non-live round-trip against deployed route module with guard enabled showed fd3 hash equals source throwaway-secret hash, 96/96. Installer gate now satisfied: install-t486-capabilities-root.sh --check exits 0, but --apply was not run. Blocker F8 remains: the patched suite fixture endpoint still waits for EOF, which no longer arrives under accepted no-half-close contract, causing timing-fragile failures. Server produced non-applied JP-run fix: /home/janpeter/idea169-t486-unblock-draft/patch-t486-suite-readloop-jp.sh mode 700 sha256 894016be9d42b83f99f04de5eaac962f4f43377e30ce39bea5536d18c6770f4f and /home/janpeter/idea169-t486-unblock-draft/patch-t486-suite-readloop.py mode 700 sha256 b9cb918373f977a535dc403ddd0d0a7fb362f3a320975e92fa47024c598a1daa. It changes only test-operator-drafts.sh from 8771d08bb2906da38cacabe73404f2c6f23a6758343c487d324e7357466d27c8 to computed 76e7dd10f57957165998cbe8ed766f7fde4f3c5732dfbb4155236da6a1f8b199. Scratch fixed-state full suite passed pass=908 fail=0 SUITE_RC=0 with zero named live path accesses, zero AF_INET/AF_INET6 sockets and zero connects. Negative evidence: t486_ count 0, /var/lib/ops-agent/t486 absent, /etc/ops-agent/secret untouched, no --live, no credential mutation/read/print/copy. mac:codex stopped its own duplicate scratch-copy run after official result arrived. --- *2026-08-26T12:32:10.767Z — mac:codex* 2026-08-26T12:31Z — T486 unblock voortgang. PR #158 is merged en deployed op scrum4me-server (`/opt/ops-agent/.install-provenance`: repo_head `6f2a6f493ae15c34c46c0f25e8ebd4eb95470885`, ops_agent_rev `4e61397a7742b5806e9f6b3d838197cd3d451695`, repo_dirty=no). Finale suitepatch applied op `/home/janpeter/idea169-t486-draft/test-operator-drafts.sh`; digest `76e7dd10f57957165998cbe8ed766f7fde4f3c5732dfbb4155236da6a1f8b199`. Fresh server-run: `suite_rc=0`, `pass=908 fail=0`, enforced syscall audit: positive openat control observed, zero named live-path access, zero AF_INET/AF_INET6 sockets/connects. Finale vijf digests voor double-GO: contain `6ad45073be89b6a527282896afc5e0279e9ec8e6d1a66f35e18446488bd0b55e`; forge `26c61d78d87e7753a47ae349f5974120eb11ad10d11f6f415f345be90f9314ae`; pg `ffc85f53a3ebfc78b956009bc6814e0e5ad698110925fd8440963c0637953b38`; README `3b29b760c8688619b6f52c233a22aca649f5e5a87bccd0baa8bb77ca8c902132`; suite `76e7dd10f57957165998cbe8ed766f7fde4f3c5732dfbb4155236da6a1f8b199`. Review body saved locally at `/Users/janpetervisser/Development/Scrum4Us/docs/reviews/2026-08-26-t486-final-digest-double-go-round1.md`. Queue reviewrequests pushed: `a91566f7-77b0-4712-b6b0-75ac92af5a11` to `scrum4me-server:claude` (still pending at 12:31Z) and `92e67758-ff8e-480c-83f8-9cfb3164548e` to `mac:codex` (claimed by `mac:43192`, no reply yet at 12:31Z). No T486 live capability install, no authority bundle mint, no credential read/print/copy/mutation and no `--live` run performed. --- *2026-08-26T13:24:17.661Z — mac:codex* 2026-08-26T13:23Z — Round-1 double-GO triage afgerond. `mac:codex` review `669c96ea-f8ff-407c-8d72-dc5c73592425` gaf GO met 0 findings. `scrum4me-server:claude` review `4e351d91-9cc2-4d96-857c-8b6e428232c6` gaf NO-GO met 1 BLOCKER, 2 MAJOR, 2 MINOR. Findings zijn tegen de serverbestanden geverifieerd en geaccepteerd: README beschreef nog onjuist dat de credential niet in de HTTP request body zit; §9 miste de 2026-08-26 wire-contract repair; suite discrimineerde de keep-alive terminal-frame stop nog niet; dubbele §3 was cosmetisch; `EXPECT_TERMINAL_EVENT` is alleen in PG load-bearing en blijft als GO-compatible minor/asymmetrie staan. Patch applied op server: README contract aangepast naar `secret_value`/`secret_transport`, §3a renumbering, §9 row 9/14 geactualiseerd, §9d toegevoegd; suite B2 uitgebreid met keep-alive response row en terminal-frame-stop mutant row. New digests: contain `6ad45073be89b6a527282896afc5e0279e9ec8e6d1a66f35e18446488bd0b55e`; forge `26c61d78d87e7753a47ae349f5974120eb11ad10d11f6f415f345be90f9314ae`; pg `ffc85f53a3ebfc78b956009bc6814e0e5ad698110925fd8440963c0637953b38`; README `416dd13820515ef30ac7bd3945d5c96b6049d6ac1569e0824022011f35560e07`; suite `c729e9aefbed4dd9ee2418926105c65cc56e2e03e4e472e2c8e44808815dc5b3`. Fresh syntax gate clean. Fresh server suite: `suite_rc=0`, `pass=911 fail=0`, with new rows for keep-alive terminal frame and mutant timeout; enforced syscall audit: positive openat control `3328608`, zero named live-path accesses, zero AF_INET/AF_INET6 sockets/connects. Backups created on server: `README.md.bak.20260826T130345Z`, `test-operator-drafts.sh.bak.20260826T130345Z`. Still no T486 live capability install, no authority bundle mint, no credential read/print/copy/mutation and no `--live` run. --- *2026-08-26T13:25:26.588Z — mac:codex* 2026-08-26T13:25Z — Round-2 reviewrequests gepusht voor finale vijf-digest pre-live binding review. Review body: `/Users/janpetervisser/Development/Scrum4Us/docs/reviews/2026-08-26-t486-final-digest-double-go-round2.md`. Queue ids: `494ce565-2396-44c8-a61c-f81d2a1644ef` to `scrum4me-server:claude`; `0062cec4-f724-4c86-9d72-51dc490176d9` to `mac:codex`. Direct na push stonden beide pending. Scope blijft read-only review; geen live install/credentialmutatie. --- *2026-08-26T15:18:34.217Z — mac:codex* T486 round3b evidence after fixing round2 review findings. Server artifact root `/home/janpeter/idea169-t486-draft`. No live install, no credential read/print/copy/mutation, no authority bundle binding performed. Applied server-only draft updates with backup stamp `20260826T143438Z`: - Runtime adapter now reads non-chunked responses until full declared response Content-Length, and chunked responses until terminating zero chunk; it no longer has the obsolete terminal-frame early-stop helper. - B2 suite now covers non-chunked Content-Length keep-alive, delayed second terminal frame inside one Content-Length body, short Content-Length body, chunked keep-alive, Content-Length-stop mutant, and chunked-stop mutant. - G7 fmut diagnostics remain in place from the prior round3 patch. Current digests: - contain-known-exposures.sh `9cf93c649e9f9314f0a8a8eecd9d4efc4d7e0a6492583b7cd9a809871828e130` - rotate-forgejo-pat.sh `1cbf5a8b9349a270db7aa7549b44ac76cdf7f3da82d156e6fc0dcbaa0363a2be` - rotate-postgres-credential.sh `7ddb8511a01f5018b815d0eb28ceb2f1847fd9e8f7e2ba0bf8b9518af284a2d3` - README.md `47c9990eee31da10efce246ac47aaad9cf10bcc0a2532253a60c0b83be5c34bb` - test-operator-drafts.sh `9e6e96c44e8acff36fea5748ed1d3b0473278fb73e01fd738d3a6f9bb03d152c` - extracted adapter hash in all three operator scripts: `514832a3e9388e1a468718a3084247aa1c8031b32a53ee28ae2f128c98d5501b` Targeted reproduction of the former mac:codex blocker now returns `adapter_rc=1`, `adapter_stdout='MULTIPLE-TERMINAL - - -'`, declared body length 180 and first frame length 89; no longer returns OK after first frame. Verification: - Functional suite run 1: `/tmp/t486-suite-round3b-20260826T143455Z.log`, `pass=916 fail=0`, rc 0. - Functional suite run 2: `/tmp/t486-suite-round3b-repeat-20260826T144449Z.log`, `pass=916 fail=0`, rc 0. - Enforced syscall audit run: `/tmp/t486-suite-round3b-audited-20260826T145828Z.log`, `pass=916 fail=0`, rc 0, positive control `3329187 openat`, zero accesses to named live paths, zero AF_INET/AF_INET6 sockets and zero connects. --- *2026-08-26T15:19:54.673Z — mac:codex* Round-3 review requests dispatched via s4m-queue after green round3b verification. - scrum4me-server:claude request `b8ffa703-d855-478f-8068-6c994e7f16c4` - mac:codex request `c7fe89f4-6288-4474-99f3-ef5eb1a09272` Awaiting reviewed replies before any authority bundle or live binding step. --- *2026-08-26T15:29:40.278Z — mac:codex* Because the `mac:codex` round-3 review request stayed pending while `scrum4me-server:claude` was claimed, a backup independent review request was dispatched to `max2:claude`: `d94a2d37-abea-4dad-9f00-eb5ee1e7d35c`. Gate remains unchanged: require two independent GO replies before any live binding. --- *2026-08-26T16:18:49.676Z — mac:codex* Round-3 replies received. Primary reviews: - mac:codex reply `4555d2b1-dfdd-4bee-9e4d-13f5ca4204de`: VERDICT GO, no findings. Verified manifest, syntax, adapter identity, B2 Content-Length/chunked keep-alive semantics, G7 fmut diagnostics, supplied logs, and absence of obsolete terminal-frame-stop references. - scrum4me-server:claude reply `12cfe719-8243-42ec-bcae-d8c27cbbbf48`: VERDICT GO, 0 blocker, 0 major, 2 minor. Round-2 findings closed; noted minor HTTP framing strictness and unexplained-but-diagnosable prior nondeterminism. Backup review: - max2:claude reply `762173a8-abe1-41cd-bca8-18e3fd1fb2c7`: VERDICT NO-GO, 1 blocker. B1 claims the 12 G7 fmut construction guards can fail silently because `mutant_tree` runs in command substitution; its `bad` output is captured and its `FAIL++` happens in a subshell. Independently verified with a minimal reproduction using the same shell shape: after `mutant_tree` calls `bad` and returns 1 inside `W="$(mutant_tree)" || return`, summary remains `pass=0 fail=0`. Decision: treat the backup B1 as valid despite the two primary GO replies. The current digest set is not bindable until the G7 harness construction guard is parent-visible and/or row-count asserted. Scope for next patch: `test-operator-drafts.sh` only; keep HTTP framing minors and other observations as follow-up notes, not part of this fix. --- *2026-08-26T16:51:40.713Z — mac:codex* 2026-08-26T16:55Z — T486 round-4 B1-delta evidence. Accepted max2:claude round-3 blocker B1: G7 `fmut()` construction failures could be hidden by command substitution (`W="$(mutant_tree ...)" || return`), so a stale sed/mutation row could disappear with `fail=0`. Server-only draft patch applied to `/home/janpeter/idea169-t486-draft/test-operator-drafts.sh`; no live install, no authority bundle binding and no credential read/print/copy/mutation performed. Current digest manifest: - contain-known-exposures.sh `9cf93c649e9f9314f0a8a8eecd9d4efc4d7e0a6492583b7cd9a809871828e130` - rotate-forgejo-pat.sh `1cbf5a8b9349a270db7aa7549b44ac76cdf7f3da82d156e6fc0dcbaa0363a2be` - rotate-postgres-credential.sh `7ddb8511a01f5018b815d0eb28ceb2f1847fd9e8f7e2ba0bf8b9518af284a2d3` - README.md `47c9990eee31da10efce246ac47aaad9cf10bcc0a2532253a60c0b83be5c34bb` - test-operator-drafts.sh `1c2abdbbb165f5ad8a6809c44c626a63430e85387d6ed480da7007921e025bb8` B1 fix: `fmut()` now creates the mutant tree in the parent shell, `mutant_tree` receives the target tree path instead of printing it through command substitution, `G7_MUTATIONS` counts successful rows, and the suite asserts exactly 12 Forge mutation rows executed. Targeted stale-mutant selftest now reports `FAIL mutation 'stale guard selftest' did not apply to any line` and `summary pass=0 fail=1`. Functional suite `/tmp/t486-suite-round4-b1-20260826T162039Z.log`: `pass=917 fail=0`, rc 0. Enforced syscall-audit suite `/tmp/t486-suite-round4-b1-audited-20260826T163021Z.log`: `pass=917 fail=0`, rc 0; positive control `3329559 openat`; zero named live-path accesses; zero AF_INET/AF_INET6 sockets/connects. Round-4 review body saved locally at `/Users/janpetervisser/Development/Scrum4Us/docs/reviews/2026-08-26-t486-final-digest-double-go-round4-b1.md`. Next: two independent review requests for the current five-file digest set before any live binding step. --- *2026-08-26T16:52:08.297Z — mac:codex* 2026-08-26T16:58Z — T486 round-4 B1 delta review requests dispatched. Body: `/Users/janpetervisser/Development/Scrum4Us/docs/reviews/2026-08-26-t486-final-digest-double-go-round4-b1.md`. Queue ids: `8a3e786c-25ca-4d82-b514-d1cfda1f1c4c` to `max2:claude`; `e4e5614c-3a9d-4cd1-974d-b3e28930654e` to `mac:codex`. Scope is read-only review of current five-file digest set; no live T486 capability install, no authority bundle binding, no `--live`, and no credential read/print/copy/mutation. --- *2026-08-26T17:23:42.756Z — mac:codex* 2026-08-26T17:25Z — T486 round-4 B1 delta review completed with two independent GO replies. Replies were acked in s4m-queue. - mac:codex reply `1d13d0ed-7f87-4829-bf7a-b99e3075630a`: GO, 0 blocker / 0 major / 0 minor. Verified current manifest, `bash -n`, G7 `mutant_tree`/`fmut` structure, absence of the old command-substitution pattern, both named logs, and absence of live operations. - max2:claude reply `607c20ea-9292-4ac4-ac56-8037ff53b605`: GO, B1 closed, 0 blocker / 0 major / 4 new minor / 6 carried-forward minor. max2 independently reproduced round-3 stale-mutation behavior as `pass=0 fail=0 rc=0` and round-4 fixed behavior as `pass=0 fail=2 rc=1`; also ran an independent audited suite on max2 with `pass=917 fail=0`, positive openat control `1838822`, zero named live-path accesses and zero AF_INET/AF_INET6 sockets/connects. GO-compatible follow-ups recorded: add equivalent row-count guards for C4/H8 mutation families; add stale-pattern guard to `cmut`; strengthen two C4 assertions to concrete post-state; fix remaining `newroot()` cleanup inertness; carry forward earlier HTTP framing/control-character/diagnostic/live-branch coverage minors. Gate result: current five-file digest set has double GO for final pre-live binding review. Still no live T486 capability install, no authority bundle binding, no `--live`, and no credential read/print/copy/mutation performed. --- *2026-08-26T17:35:04.675Z — mac:codex* 2026-08-26T17:36Z — Live capability install not executed yet. During preflight for JP-approved live step, found a binding scope gap: the round-4 double-GO covered the five operator/runbook files, not the separate `/home/janpeter/idea169-t486-unblock-draft` installer bundle. The existing plan explicitly requires double-GO review of the unblock bundle before root installation/authority minting. Preflight evidence before mutation: `sudo install-t486-capabilities-root.sh --check` returned rc 0 and reported all gates OK; live state remains `t486_key_count=0`, `/var/lib/ops-agent/t486` absent, `/usr/lib/ops-agent/t486` absent, ops-agent active. Running `test-unblock-draft.sh` initially failed (`pass=80 fail=9`) because the non-live unblock bundle was not rebaselined to the round-4 operator digests and still expected stale patch states. Patched only non-live files under `/home/janpeter/idea169-t486-unblock-draft` (`README.md`, `test-unblock-draft.sh`, `patch-t486-suite-readloop-jp.sh`), with backups; no `/etc`, `/var/lib`, service restart or credential action. Re-run selftest `/tmp/t486-unblock-draft-test-20260826T173354Z.log`: rc 0, `pass=89 fail=0`. Installer check `/tmp/t486-install-check-post-rebaseline-20260826T173417Z.log`: rc 0, contract satisfied, `--apply` permitted by script. New root-gate review body saved locally: `/Users/janpetervisser/Development/Scrum4Us/docs/reviews/2026-08-26-t486-unblock-bundle-root-gate-round1.md`. Reviewer ask explicitly includes whether adding t486 allowlist entries is safe while `/usr/lib/ops-agent/t486` helper path is absent. Next step: two independent review requests; no live mutation until double-GO. --- *2026-08-26T17:35:24.140Z — mac:codex* 2026-08-26T17:37Z — Root-gate review requests dispatched for the rebaselined T486 unblock bundle. Queue ids: `79c49363-1f28-4ef8-95b9-9c4e99146aa3` to `scrum4me-server:claude`; `a387109b-c1a3-4371-804c-6bb9e1cc1c2a` to `mac:codex`. Scope read-only review only; no live install, no authority binding, no `--live`, no credential action. --- *2026-08-26T17:43:21.811Z — mac:codex* 2026-08-26T17:45Z — T486 unblock bundle root-gate round 1 completed: NO-GO. Replies acked. `mac:codex` reply `2834312c-9a23-4ce8-8f22-a645569f2868`: GO, 0 blocker / 0 major / 1 minor. `scrum4me-server:claude` reply `11141ec2-2d96-440e-a984-6846ec6ceb8c`: NO-GO, 1 blocker / 2 major. Findings verified and accepted: 1. BLOCKER rollback mode: `install-t486-capabilities-root.sh` backs up `/etc/ops-agent/commands.yml` with `cp -a` then `chmod 0600` on the backup, but rollback copies it back with `cp -a` and no mode correction. Live whitelist is `0644 root:root`; `ops-agent.service` runs `User=ops-agent Group=ops-agent`; a rollback after restart/active/key-count failure could leave commands.yml unreadable and ops-agent crash-looping. 2. MAJOR vacuous gates/digest pinning: F4/F5 can report OK if operator files are skipped; F6 checks absence of old `JSON.stringify({ code })` instead of presence of request echo; installer itself does not pin the five operator digests. 3. MAJOR helper sequencing: `/usr/lib/ops-agent` is absent, while installer would add 22 standing grants to `/usr/lib/ops-agent/t486/<name>`. This is immediate fail-closed but misleading and allows later helper drop to activate grants without this gate rerunning. Result: do not run `sudo /home/janpeter/idea169-t486-unblock-draft/install-t486-capabilities-root.sh --apply --acknowledge-readme-section-2`. No live capability install, authority binding, `--live`, or credential action performed. Review record updated locally: `/Users/janpetervisser/Development/Scrum4Us/docs/reviews/2026-08-26-t486-unblock-bundle-root-gate-round1.md`. ## Oplossing _Nog geen oplossing._

janpeter added the

severity/s2

label

2026-08-26 08:58:43 +02:00

No labels

severity/s2

severity/s3

No milestone

No project

No assignees

1 participant

Notifications

Due date

The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference

janpeter/Ops-dashboard#155

No description provided.

Rows
Columns