[ISS-18] DEPLOY sha-guard skipt na een mislukte deploy die al gepulld had: oude build blijft draaien #235
Open
opened 2026-10-19 16:37:37 +02:00 by janpeter
·
0 comments
No Branch/Tag specified
main
docs-audit/cmvetfb0f02jeow7rqkkrbpdb
fix/iss-7-plan-paths
fix/iss-6-harness-worktree-cleanup
docs-audit/cmvbyjfqk02ousy7rh1d5swaf
claude/idee-attach-modus
fix/dispatch-submit-404-hint
docs-audit/cmv93nqxf00slem7rg9hp5u0f
claude/iss-17-idea-link
docs-audit/cmv7o7wa000pam97reoqhcmdj
feat/idea-249-record-issue-scope
feat/idea-249-issue-phase
docs-audit/cmv68rygv00hqin7rpw9niqmt
claude/idea-251-idea-link
claude/st074-estimate-history-list-price
fix/iss-16-agent-chat-token-scope
docs-audit/cmv3dwg1k004hz07rqzwdlley
feat/m50-1a-agent-chat
feat/iss-9-close-task-stops
fix/iss-2-claim-bound-stop
plan/iss-2-cancel-unstarted
feat/idea-243-job-notify
feat/m45-3-local-llm-opruimen
fix/iss58-drop-mcp-drain-stamp
fix/iss15-review-static-no-registry
docs-audit/cmv0j0o6t0069oc7rfn6op51p
fix/iss1-verify-default-branch
docs-audit/cmuz3ktfm019yo07rwodthg4m
feat/m45-2b-harness
codex/ppe-task-status
docs-audit/cmuw8ozn900l5z87rlpf2mx7b
fix/iss12-signed-off-unstarted
docs-audit/cmuut96fv011yhb7rskn61ft0
fix/iss-11-bootstrap-nullable-rebind
test/t1972-recovery-http
feat/t1972-recovery-usage
feat/t1972-dispatch-usage
docs-audit/cmurydk3j00a9747r68iqqa1h
feat/m41-reply-addresses-list
feat/m41-reviewer-kind
feat/m41-review-contract
fix/stdio-canary-test-timeout
docs/agent-guide-startflow
feat/notes-tools-pbi30
docs-audit/cmukt69k3003zk47roinpfpfw
feat/m3-local-llm-task-jobs
fix/packaged-release-test-timeout
fix/api-token-expiry
fix/wait-for-job-listener-leak
docs-audit/cmuhyah5f003wmt7rg70umy5b
feat/m2-local-llm-claim
fix/listen-client-error-handler
fix/iss-1-repair-script-scope
fix/ci-refuse-stale-pr-head
fix/ci-postgres-port-conflict
fix/story-rollup-excluded
fix/mcp-dispatch-list-timeout
feat/idea-213-dispatch
fix/compare-diff-authenticated
feat/m39-mcp-db-aware-snapshot
feat/m39-mcp-shared-shim
fix/iss-3-default-branch
feat/werkbackup-m38
claude/blissful-heisenberg-70a6d6
codex/idea-169-forgejo-ci-host-mcp
codex/idea-169-runtime-rebaseline-mcp
codex/fix-verify-diff-maxbuffer
codex/idea-187-companion-secret-hotfix
feat/sprint-06zbas3p
feat/queue-work-item-ids
feat/agent-guide-issues
feat/issue-tracker
fix/db-label-instance-fallback
fix/db-application-name
feat/m32-archivering
feat/m30-p0.4-pin-bump
feat/product-doc-cap-250k
claude/jolly-jemison-74bdd1
docs/rules-file-revisie3
feat/queue-vocab-parity
feat/queue-kimi-enums
docs/rules-codex-bestemming
docs/rules-file-actief
docs/testing-typecheck-scope
fix/integration-tests-serieel
claude/awesome-rosalind-7b450b
fix/typecheck-shared-submodule-bump
feat/queue-fase3-hardening
feat/queue-tools-push
fix/commit-id-guard
feat/queue-tools-fase2b
fix/review-verdict-comment
feat/queue-tools-fase2
claude/s4m-queue-chat-search-244a7c
chore/gen-schema-drop-url-strip
fix/mcp-stdio-orphan-leak
codex/codex-model-catalog
fix/task-review-poison-loop
codex/worker-usage-mcp-capture
feat/spec-plan-loop-max-rondes
fix/m20-plan-verdict-same-race
fix/m23-spec-maker-done-and-verdict-race
feat/m23-idea-spec-pipeline
fix/noodrem-cancel-guard
feat/m20-plan-review-loop
feat/on-demand-repo-clone-spec
feat/M19-allowlist-agent-docs
codex/forgejo-ci-20260707
feat/M19-docs-audit-job
feat/M22-auto-merge-reliability
feat/M21-sprint-batch-auto-deploy
fix/deploy-prompt-fail-loud-pin
fix/story-done-level-trigger
fix/auto-pr-reuse-only-open
feat/idea-chat-channel-tools
fix/tier-defer-claimability
chore/host-mcp-update-script
fix/deploy-prompt-ops-agent-contract
feat/idea-brainstorm-skill
feat/M17-deploy-job
feat/idea-chat-followup-mcp
feat/idea-chat-mcp
claude/job-kind-config-phase3
claude/mcp-review-done-gate
claude/mcp-unified-reviewlog
claude/question-channel-mcp
codex/opus-48-job-defaults
claude/idea-mcp-tools
feat/copilot-content-policy-mcp
feat/copilot-mcp-foundation
claude/nifty-shaw-90609d
refactor/wait-for-job-sprint-scope-types
fix/dockerfile-bash
fix/review-done-preserve-summary-trace
feat/http-graceful-shutdown
feat/codex-pr-review-phase2
fix/idea-review-plan-done-gate
feat/codex-plan-review-phase1
fix/tier-preference-enum-ordinal
chore/package-repo-only-metadata
docs/audit-2026-06-06
fix/idea-kinds-allow-agent-guide
feat/mcp-manual-idea-context
fix/product-worktree-default-branch
feat/worker-capability-scheduler
feat/sprint-353x8t4e
feat/mcp-doc-index
fix/defer-worktree-cleanup-usage-hook
chore/scrum4me-methodiek-binding
fix/worktree-submodule-and-codegen
codex/manual-job-editor-phase3-mcp
codex/fix-cross-repo-rollback-cleanup
fix/rollback-cleans-worktree-and-executions
fix/host-mcp-instance-id-fallback
chore/M16-fase3-shared-bump
cleanup/stale-scrum4me-vendor-refs
feat/M16-platform-split-shared-bootstrap
claude/naughty-brown-2be56e
feat/http-mcp-server
feat/doc-tool-discipline
claude/peaceful-dirac-979dd8
feat/pbi-102-pbi-doc-linking
fix/heartbeat-token-user-id-refresh
feat/PBI-13-forgejo-pr-urls
feat/story-pxzrkdbk
fix/idea-plan-reviewed-no-silent-approve
fix/cross-repo-worktree-and-pr
feat/sprint-gk6h5cu0
feat/PBI-12-sprint-tools
fix/classify-pseudo-paths
fix/attach-worktree-writes-branch
fix/prepare-done-uses-db-branch
chore/sync-schema
fix/idea-prompts-payload-path
fix/idea-kinds-permission-mode
feat/queue-loop-extraction
feat/pbi-67-job-config
feat/sprint-aolrn6ui
feat/skipped-exit-route
feat/sprint-worker
feat/sprint-flow
feat/pbi-fail-cascade
chore/sync-idea-prompts
chore/heartbeat-10s
claude/hardcore-shtern-3d6db0
feat/worker-quota-tools
feat/create-task-repo-url
feat/auto-merge-after-pr
fix/idea-job-done-skip-verify
fix/idea-job-claim-leftjoin
feat/m12-idea-jobs
feat/story-mhj9f2la
feat/cross-repo-task-routing
fix/verify-gate-required-level
docs/branch-per-story-flow
fix/heartbeat-self-heal-on-missing-record
fix/presence-bootstrap-before-connect
feat/plan-snapshot-verify-tool
feat/story-promotion-filter
feat/mcp-authoring-tools
feat/M11-question-tools
deploy/main-3ab3c3efa24d
deploy/main-511912a85dc0
deploy/main-276989eb231b
deploy/main-b9a028adb87e
deploy/main-de1afd25e428
deploy/main-d2251f7b11e8
deploy/main-cd556f2b5f92
deploy/main-bceba2e321e3
deploy/main-bd7be682635e
deploy/main-1fc33f8c1b6e
deploy/main-85be5eb02b97
deploy/main-4eb0cd1796cd
deploy/main-6b31906c1b90
deploy/main-b4c61987254f
deploy/main-e017bab0bfff
deploy/main-a843a79fce0b
deploy/main-5af973636c3f
deploy/main-8bbc0fd22141
deploy/main-285c98ae3fc6
deploy/main-390c391ce455
deploy/main-c20688e8b3e5
deploy/main-bef26bfc4948
deploy/main-99ff2618825a
deploy/main-201f7eb5877e
deploy/main-84ab210f9a29
deploy/iss5-1c81b7af
deploy/iss3-db519dc9
deploy/m38-033a2074
deploy/idea-169-f222f692
No labels
severity/s2
severity/s3
severity/s4
Milestone
Clear milestone
No items
No milestone
Projects
Clear projects
No items
No project
Assignees
Clear assignees
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".
No due date set.
Dependencies
No dependencies set.
Reference
janpeter/scrum4me-mcp#235
Loading…
Add table
Add a link
Reference in a new issue
No description provided.
Delete branch "%!s()"
Deleting a branch is permanent. Although the deleted branch may continue to exist for a short time before it actually gets removed, it CANNOT be undone in most cases. Continue?
Status: new · Severity: s2_critical · Gemeld door: mac:claude · Occurrences: 1 (laatst: 2026-10-19T14:29:26.576Z) · Aangemaakt: 2026-10-19T14:29:26.576Z
Registratie
Waargenomen 2026-10-19 bij de Scrum4Me-deploy van
mainfdea3f6c(IDEA-264 I2, #396/#400, plus IDEA-267 #397 met een migratie).Volgorde.
cmvfcdk75002a2717xzkgxojv(MANUAL, viadispatch_job): FAILED bij stap 6/12prepare_policy_bundle, exit 3, door een gewijzigde policy-hash (1a8d5448…naard3d1e5e8…, door0a56c53b). Dat gebeurde nagit_pull/git_submodule_update, dus de servercheckout staat opfdea3f6c.npm_ci, de migratie, de build en de herstart zijn niet gedraaid.cmvfcl2fe002d2717n9res8ug: SKIPPEDmerge_sha_already_deployed, na 19 s.Oorzaak.
src/prompts/deploy/run.md, stap 4 (sha-guard):repo_contains_shadoetgit merge-base --is-ancestor <doel-sha> HEADop de checkout. Na een deploy die nagit_pullfaalde, bevat de checkout de sha al, terwijl de draaiende app nooit opnieuw gebouwd of herstart is en de migratie niet is uitgevoerd. De guard meet "staat in de checkout" en niet "is met succes gedeployd". Zo slaat elke herstart-deploy over, ook "Deploy nu", het herstelpad datdeploy-control.mdvoor een failure noemt. De failure-blokkade blijft dan ook staan, want alleen een DONE-deploy heft hem op.Gevolg. De server draait nog de oude build, terwijl de checkout op de nieuwe sha staat. Een migratie (hier
product_access_stepsvan #397) loopt niet. Een herstart vanscrum4me-webzou een oude.nextcombineren met een nieuwere broncheckout.Mogelijke remedie (te beslissen): de guard toetst tegen de sha van de laatste DONE DEPLOY-job voor het product (of een door de flow na een geslaagde run geschreven marker), niet tegen de checkout-HEAD. Of een FAILED deploy voor dezelfde sha zonder
resolved_atsluit de skip uit. Regressie: FAILED nagit_pullen daarna opnieuw dezelfde sha, die moet deployen.Workaround nu: de flow
update_scrum4me_webdirect in het Ops-dashboard draaien. Die heeft geen sha-guard.Onderzoek
Nog geen onderzoek.
Oplossing
Nog geen oplossing.